This 2023 Job Market Defies Expectations - But No One Acts Surprised

The 2023 job market is incredible.

With upwards revisions to March and April, this May jobs report adds 432,000 new jobs to the 2023 total. The average for the first 5 months of 2023 is 314,000 jobs created.

How strong is the rate of 314,000 jobs per month? It is 3.6X what it averaged from 2000 through 2019. A year with a monthly average of 314,000 jobs created would fall into the top 10 for all the years since 1939, when records began.

Four variables make job creation at this rate absurd (in a good way).
1. We began 2023 with 3.4% unemployment - the lowest it had been in 54 years.
2. The Fed has been dramatically raising interest rates. 15 months ago, their overnight rates were 0.05%. That rate is now 5.05% - its highest in 16 years.
3. 10,000 baby boomers are hitting retirement age every single day.
4. 2021 and 2022 rank first and second all-time for job creation. 12 million jobs created in 2 years. That’s absurd and would suggest that the rate of job creation might “correct” to a lower rate.

Any one of these four variables would be a perfectly plausible explanation for a slow year of job creation in 2023. And yet the economy is creating jobs at a rate that would make headlines and create buzz during FDR, Reagan or Clinton’s presidencies. (FDR – like Biden - had 2 years with a more rapid rate of job creation than 2023. Reagan and Clinton each had only 1.)

Of course, we will find a way to dismiss this and move on to the next bit of handwringing to replace our fretting about the price of eggs. And the memes will be catchy - so much better than - yawn - data.