In the NBA, the median player makes about $6.4 million annually, and the highest-paid player makes more than $62 million. In the NFL, median compensation is roughly $1.2 million, with the highest-paid players earning more than $50 million a year. In Major League Baseball, the median is $1.4 million, and the highest-paid player earns nearly $62 million.
Now a question: Would you say that the leagues paying these incredible salaries are highly competitive? Or would you say they are highly regulated?
The answer, of course, is both.
And the games are better for it.
If you watch a football game this weekend, play will be interrupted about every minute or two by an official's ruling, even for something as seemingly trivial as where to mark the ball. Then play resumes, and those extraordinarily talented athletes are again putting everything they have into creating something spectacular.
In basketball, referees regularly blow their whistles throughout the game. Free throws, often awarded as penalties for fouls, account for roughly 16% of all points scored. That's about one point in six.
Clearly, Americans love their sports. And clearly, the games that command their attention are both fiercely competitive and tightly regulated.
I would argue that we have enormous gains to make by bringing that same mentality to the economy.
Consider AI and the extraordinary buildout of data centers.
I'm quite optimistic about AI. But this is no trivial transition we're making.
I love religious freedom. Yet the transition toward religious freedom in the West involved centuries of sometimes violent conflict. Today, relatively few people who enjoy religious freedom would willingly surrender it to live in a society where someone else dictated their beliefs but the transition into this reality was costly.
I love the fact that we can so easily order manufactured goods that are higher quality, more varied, and more personalized than at almost any time in history, and have them delivered to our doors. But the transition to industrial capitalism, global supply chains, and extraordinary consumer choice was chaotic and disruptive. Like it or not, Marx was right about some of the egregious costs imposed by capital. And yet, over time, capitalism and technological progress have helped make billions of people richer.
Transitions into new economies and new possibilities are stressful in a hundred different ways.
But they are transitions worth making.
On the other side of the stress, chaos, and uncertainty can lie a better world.
Figuring out how to integrate AI into our lives and economies will be disruptive and stressful. But it is also full of promise: better treatments and cures for diseases, perhaps even breakthroughs against aging; fewer barriers to creating new and interesting work, products, services, and entertainment; and new opportunities for generating wealth.
Making that transition successfully will not come from choosing between competition and regulation. It will come from getting better at both.
Communities need to embrace the possibilities of more rapid product development, improved processes, and entirely new kinds of jobs and work made possible by rapidly evolving AI. They need to accelerate the innovations that deliver value while quickly abandoning proposals, startups, and inventions that don't.
Communities also need to manage the costs of this transformation. They need to regulate carbon emissions from the data-center buildout and use the economic potential of this technology to upgrade power grids and related infrastructure, creating benefits that spill over into surrounding communities. They need to soften the blow of job displacement while making it easier for people to move into new kinds of work that may be more engaging and more lucrative.
And they need to do all of this while the technology, the economy, and the possibilities are changing rapidly.
This will require something quite different from the traditional debate over big government versus small government.
It will require more grassroots experimentation, faster regulatory responses, and more public-sector entrepreneurship.
It will require far more private-sector competition, with entrepreneurs and businesses doing what players on the field do: experimenting, competing, innovating, and performing at extraordinary levels.
And it will require officials who can make timely calls, establish clear rules, correct problems, and then get out of the way so play can resume. (And note that we don't debate what the rules "should be" during the play. That's a discussion to be had off the field or court. Similarly, we will have intense, prolonged debates about what the rules should be in places like state and federal legislative bodies. The on-field officiating should be close to play, based on defined rules, and made as quickly as possible before resuming play. Debate about what the rules are will need to be separate from rulings.]
More competition. More regulation. Less delay.
The goal isn't to maximize rules. It's to maximize the quality of the game.
And this is where public-sector entrepreneurship becomes essential.
Rather than treating regulations and public institutions as permanent structures that change only after years of political conflict, we need to become more entrepreneurial about governance itself.
Try new approaches. Test them locally. Measure their results. Scale what works. Abandon what doesn't. Change rulings on the field when experience demonstrates a better way.
Imagine referees who required a congressional hearing before deciding whether a player had stepped out of bounds. Or who insisted that a ruling made decades ago could never be reconsidered, no matter how much the game had changed.
That's hardly the kind of officiating we'd tolerate in sports. Why should we tolerate its equivalent in governing an economy undergoing extraordinary transformation?
Will this mean more regulation?
Yes. Just as we see in the sports Americans love.
Will this mean more competition, more pressure to perform at higher levels?
Yes. Again, just as we see in those sports.
Will it mean becoming more willing to change ourselves and our institutions, creating more options and improving lives rather than protecting ourselves from progress and competition?
Yes.
But does it also mean preserving norms, traditions, and institutions that communities cherish, even in the midst of dramatic change?
Yes, when that is what those communities choose.
Entrepreneurs should have extraordinary freedom to propose new possibilities. But the entrepreneurial few should not have unilateral authority to determine what kind of society everyone else must inhabit. Those decisions belong in democratic institutions accountable to the people.
We have to be deliberate about the next economy we create. And we have to be quick in processing options, making decisions, and correcting mistakes.
Done properly, we could have as much experimentation with institutions as we have invention of technologies.
We need to know when to step in and make a call and when to step back and let play resume. We want an economy in which the best solutions have a chance to win, the rules are understood, and the outcomes are broadly regarded as fair.
But there's another important difference between professional sports and the economy.
In sports, only a few extraordinary people get onto the field. In the next economy, we need to find ways to get more of us into the game.
This means expanding opportunities for entrepreneurship in both the private and public sectors. More people should have the opportunity not simply to adapt to the next economy, but to participate in creating it.
It means giving communities more agency in determining which innovations they embrace, which costs they will accept, and which possibilities they want to pursue.
And perhaps most importantly, it means reducing the win-lose outcomes of economic change while expanding the win-win possibilities that have defined so much of human progress.
In sports, every contest produces winners and losers. In an innovative economy, success need not require someone else's defeat. A new cure, a cleaner source of energy, a more effective institution, or a technology that makes us all more productive can leave millions of people better off simultaneously.
We can move toward a less zero-sum world, one in which more people have more choices about who they can become and what kind of lives they can lead.
Like the sports Americans love, our next economy will need more competition and more effective regulation.
Unlike those sports, though, we should aspire to an economy in which more people can participate, more people can win, and the rules evolve along with the game.
We won't be wearing uniforms. But we should all have a chance to get onto the field.
No comments:
Post a Comment